Story Texas Senate · Oct 9

Trump asks Supreme Court to let Big Bend border project resume

The Texas Tribune's headline · Read the article

55accounts posting
71,238likes on their posts
72 hfrom first post to last

Posts on X we collected that mention it, Oct 9, 8:00 AM CT to Nov 18, 9:35 AM CT. Posts are not people, and replies include bots.

It started here

Owen Gregorian Oct 9, 8:00 AM CT

Judge Blocks Utah’s Demand That Websites See Through VPNs | Mike Masnick, Techdirt Over the last few years, with Congress completely incompetent and a massive moral panic about tech raging, states have stepped up to try to regulate the internet any way they can. Even after the Supreme Court reminded states that the First Amendment still exists online and their varied attempts to regulate speech faced serious constitutional hurdles, it hasn’t cooled state legislators’ and governors’ enthusiasm for pushing through a patchwork of confusing (and sometimes conflicting) laws. And of course, with the Supreme Court’s prudish ruling in Free Speech Coalition v. Paxton, the Court seemed to say states could ignore the First Amendment so long as they shouted “porn!” and “children!” in proximity to each other. One estimate says that over 300 state bills to regulate social media and kid safety on the internet were introduced in 2025 alone. And, from the beginning, some of us have wondered how states could even try to regulate the internet at all, given that the dormant Commerce Clause (DCC) is (in theory) supposed to limit the states’ ability to regulate commerce that runs across state lines, as the internet obviously does. While the DCC has come up in a few cases , it’s mostly been as an extra throw-in and given significantly less attention than other arguments. So, it’s good, if somewhat surprising, to see that a federal judge in Utah has blocked a key piece of that state’s latest ( in a long line ) attempt to age verify parts of the internet. Utah already required adult content sites to age verify Utah users back in 2023. This year’s amendment added a provision saying that anyone “actually located” in Utah counts, VPN or no VPN. Aylo, the internet’s largest adult content company, sued to block that new provision. And, so far it has worked, with the court granting a preliminary injunction against that provision. But what’s most interesting is that the ruling relies on the dormant Commerce Clause, though in a very narrow way. The new law was crazy in all sorts of ways, effectively demanding that websites see through VPN usage to figure out where a person really is, even if they appear to be somewhere else. Even Utah agreed that this isn’t something anyone can actually do with certainty: However, all the parties agree that IP-based geolocation is underinclusive because it fails to account for technologies that obscure a user’s location. These technologies, including virtual private networks (“VPNs”) and proxy servers, mask a user’s true location by routing traffic through IP addresses corresponding to different geographic locations. VPNs and location-obfuscation technologies have entirely legitimate purposes—such as securing communications on public networks, preventing websites from harvesting personal data, and circumventing censorship by oppressive governments. But these technologies can also be used to circumvent IP-based geolocation restrictions, such as the one used by Aylo for its free sites. Utah presumably passed the actual-location provision to address this issue. But both parties also agree that there is no way for a website operator to determine a user’s physical location with perfect certainty. Aylo argues that Utah’s actual location requirement means that Aylo must “impose age verification on every user of their platforms, everywhere in the world” because it is impossible to know for sure whether any given user actually is in Utah. The court then rejects a bunch of Aylo’s other arguments before zeroing in on the one that lands: because Utah’s law demands perfect geolocation — an impossibility — the only way to comply is to age verify absolutely everyone, everywhere. That clearly impacts commerce far beyond Utah’s borders… and thus triggers the dormant Commerce Clause: The law requires geolocation perfection, but the parties agree that current technological advancements do not allow an entity to perfectly (1) detect VPN/proxy users, or (2) geolocate where all of those VPN/proxy users are accessing the site from. Aylo could not ensure compliance with the law without age-verifying all users. Unlike a law that merely increases a company’s cost of running its business, the actual-location provision in practice requires an entity to perform age verification services for every user visiting its site from any location because the entity would violate the law if even one of those users happened to be obfuscating their location from Utah. As a result, the law “cannot effectively be limited” to primarily regulating those in Utah obfuscating their location “over the Internet because no such [technology to detect those users in every instance] exist[s].” Because the actual-location provision, in most cases, directly regulates an entity’s interactions with those who have no connection to Utah, it likely creates too much direct regulation of wholly out-of-state conduct to be lawful under the dormant Commerce Clause. The court also finds that the law fails the ( recently weakened ) Pike balancing test , burdening interstate commerce far out of proportion to its local benefits: As an example, Aylo has approximately 28 million active visitors to its sites each month from the United States. Because the law requires perfection in the absence of perfect geolocation tools, Aylo would need to verify those 28 million users—whether located in Salt Lake City, Boston, New Orleans, Anchorage, or Honolulu—to ensure compliance and avoid liability. Indeed, every entity that hosts material applicable under the actual-location provision would need to age verify all of the entity’s users nationwide or inevitably violate the law. This reach is expansive and would involve massive numbers of wholly out-of-state interactions. The ruling is fairly narrow, though, and the court more or less tells Utah how to fix it: by adding a reasonableness clause that gives Aylo (and any others under the law) some leeway in how they determine the location of visitors: Utah argues that the actual-location provision is indirect because technology “allow[s] Aylo to reasonably and feasibly attempt to age assure VPN-using Utahns, [so] any decision by Aylo to instead age-verify all users would be a voluntary business choice, not an effect forced by Utah law.” The court does not doubt that this is the Attorney General’s good faith intention. But, as discussed above, the actual-location provision does not contain a reasonableness or feasibility standard and would therefore impose liability every time an entity did not perform age verification on a user located in Utah. Unlike Online Merchants Guild, the nationwide reach of the actual-location provision would not be due to an entity’s choice on how to structure its business. Rather, it would be “inevitable” that the entity would need to comply by age verifying every outside-of-Utah user on its site to avoid liability. The court makes the same point again when it notes that there are “less burdensome means” to get what Utah says it wants: Second, the significant local interests served by the actual-location provision can be achieved through less burdensome means. To be sure, the law involves a substantial safety interest in preventing minors from accessing harmful sexual material, which falls squarely within Utah’s traditional regulatory power. But Utah has represented that a law requiring “feasible and reasonable [geolocation] methods,” instead of perfection, would promote the same interests served by the actual-location provision. Because of this unique posture, Utah’s weighty interests could clearly be “promoted with . . . a lesser impact on interstate activities.” Thus, Aylo has shown that the actual-location provision likely imposes an excessive burden on interstate commerce in relation to its local benefits. So, while it’s nice to see one of the many state internet regulations blocked on DCC grounds, it seems incredibly likely that Utah will just have its legislature rewrite the law (again), add a “reasonable” or “feasible” standard, and take another crack at it. While that would have the benefit of not requiring companies to do the literal impossible thing of seeing through VPNs to figure out where people really are, it won’t do much to stop yet another silly age verification law from existing.

4 replies0 reposts11 likesOpen on X

How it spread

noonSatnoonSunnoonMonpeak Fri 8 AM

Posts we collected about it, by the hour they were posted, Central time.

The loudest reactions swipe

Eric Daugherty Oct 27, 1:50 PM CT

🚨 BREAKING: Justice Sam Alito and the U.S. Supreme Court just REJECTED a left-wing emergency bid to revive a 2024 Biden regulation that let immigration judges indefinitely delay deportation cases — with ZERO noted dissents BIG WIN! 🇺🇸 In June, Texas AG Ken Paxton and the Trump DOJ teamed up to vacate the Biden "administrative closure" rule nationwide and block the government from adopting a similar loophole down the line And it worked. Democrat-run cities rushed to SCOTUS to save the rule, literally arguing in court that deporting illegal aliens would cost them "taxpayers" 🤡 Immigration judges MUST actually decide deportation cases instead of delaying forever!

144 replies4,348 reposts18,191 likesOpen on X

🇺🇸 Mike Davis 🇺🇸 Oct 12, 4:14 PM CT

Dear Texas Voters: Four Supreme Court justices are in their 70s. There will be many lower court seats to fill over the next 2 years. Do you want Paxton confirming Trump’s judges? Or Talarico blocking them?

291 replies4,072 reposts14,111 likesOpen on X

Laura Ingraham Oct 21, 11:32 AM CT

The Bushes support court packing? Good to know. Trump is 💯. It was never Dem v. Republican. It’s a one-party Establishment that protects itself at all costs.

Democrat Texas Senate Candidate James Talarico: “I think that the Supreme Court needs to be overhauled”

227 replies1,723 reposts6,785 likesOpen on X

Joe Oltmann Nov 17, 12:54 PM CT

So the conservatives screaming that Ken Paxton went soft this month… slow down and read what is actually going on before you join the pile on, because I think the man is doing the one thing almost nobody in our movement ever does, which is think past the next election. Paxton's office dropped the Texas lawsuit against CAIR and the Muslim Brotherhood yesterday, dropped the NCAA women's sports suit four days before that, ended the Annunciation House and FIEL Houston cases on November 9th and pulled the parental access claims against Epic Systems on November 10th. Social media lost its mind. And yet nobody stopped to ask the obvious question… who owns those cases in January? Nathan Johnson does. The Democrat taking over the AG office has already promised a top to bottom review of everything Paxton filed and said on November 5th that "those done for political stuntery are going to be terminated." He already told you he will not go after the out of state doctors mailing abortion pills into Texas, and Governor elect Gina Hinojosa has pledged to rescind Abbott's CAIR designation. So what do you think happens to a lawsuit filed in the name of the State of Texas when the man who filed it walks out the door? It belongs to the next guy, and the next guy can flip the state's position, release the defendant and sign a consent decree that binds Texas for years. Ask Harris County. Their bail settlement from 2019 still governs today because a federal court refused to dissolve it in October. Let me put it to you like this. A case filed as a sword comes back as a shield for CAIR, signed by the State of Texas, and that is how the rot works… they lose the argument, then they win the office, then they settle the case with themselves. The CAIR and NCAA dismissals were without prejudice, which means nothing was decided and a Republican AG can refile. The NCAA already changed its policy after President Trump's executive order. Annunciation House and FIEL went with prejudice and those claims are gone, but the Texas Supreme Court precedent Paxton won on the way stays on the books. Make no mistake, I would rather we were winning these cases to final judgment. But we did not keep the office, and a lawsuit is only as conservative as the lawyer holding it. Is it uncomfortable? Yes. Is it the smart move? Also yes. Now here is the part that matters. Wisconsin passed a law in 2018 requiring legislative approval before any settlement that limits the state's future enforcement power. Texas Legislature, the minute you gavel in, do the same, and stop letting an election hand the winner a loaded docket to turn on the people who lost. End stop.

This is 100 percent correct. Paxton is taking a hit because leaving these cases open will allow the incoming team to make settlements that are counter to the interests of the people of Texas. Do not be led by ravings on social media. Whatever you may think of him, the man is taking a bullet to protect Texans.

164 replies1,604 reposts6,464 likesOpen on X

Sara Gonzales Oct 21, 10:16 AM CT

James Talarico says he is in favor of “overhauling” the Supreme Court and says packing the court is on the table. Texas, do not fall for his moderate rhetoric. He is a dangerous radical who must be defeated.

263 replies1,791 reposts6,208 likesOpen on X

Dana Loesch Oct 21, 10:09 AM CT

This is a greater threat than disliking Paxton

Democrat Texas Senate Candidate James Talarico: “I think that the Supreme Court needs to be overhauled”

97 replies872 reposts3,863 likesOpen on X

Where the race stands

Senate

James Talarico50%
Ken Paxton44%

YouGov's numbers, not VoteCow's · September 28 - October 5, 2026 · 3,625 likely voters · ±3% · Release

Next storyJames Talarico seen after 13-day absence due to illness | Fox News Video45 accounts · 71,027 likes

More stories