Joe Oltmann Nov 17, 12:54 PM CT
So the conservatives screaming that Ken Paxton went soft this month… slow down and read what is actually going on before you join the pile on, because I think the man is doing the one thing almost nobody in our movement ever does, which is think past the next election.
Paxton's office dropped the Texas lawsuit against CAIR and the Muslim Brotherhood yesterday, dropped the NCAA women's sports suit four days before that, ended the Annunciation House and FIEL Houston cases on November 9th and pulled the parental access claims against Epic Systems on November 10th. Social media lost its mind. And yet nobody stopped to ask the obvious question… who owns those cases in January?
Nathan Johnson does. The Democrat taking over the AG office has already promised a top to bottom review of everything Paxton filed and said on November 5th that "those done for political stuntery are going to be terminated." He already told you he will not go after the out of state doctors mailing abortion pills into Texas, and Governor elect Gina Hinojosa has pledged to rescind Abbott's CAIR designation. So what do you think happens to a lawsuit filed in the name of the State of Texas when the man who filed it walks out the door? It belongs to the next guy, and the next guy can flip the state's position, release the defendant and sign a consent decree that binds Texas for years. Ask Harris County. Their bail settlement from 2019 still governs today because a federal court refused to dissolve it in October.
Let me put it to you like this. A case filed as a sword comes back as a shield for CAIR, signed by the State of Texas, and that is how the rot works… they lose the argument, then they win the office, then they settle the case with themselves. The CAIR and NCAA dismissals were without prejudice, which means nothing was decided and a Republican AG can refile. The NCAA already changed its policy after President Trump's executive order. Annunciation House and FIEL went with prejudice and those claims are gone, but the Texas Supreme Court precedent Paxton won on the way stays on the books.
Make no mistake, I would rather we were winning these cases to final judgment. But we did not keep the office, and a lawsuit is only as conservative as the lawyer holding it. Is it uncomfortable? Yes. Is it the smart move? Also yes.
Now here is the part that matters. Wisconsin passed a law in 2018 requiring legislative approval before any settlement that limits the state's future enforcement power. Texas Legislature, the minute you gavel in, do the same, and stop letting an election hand the winner a loaded docket to turn on the people who lost.
End stop.
This is 100 percent correct. Paxton is taking a hit because leaving these cases open will allow the incoming team to make settlements that are counter to the interests of the people of Texas. Do not be led by ravings on social media. Whatever you may think of him, the man is taking a bullet to protect Texans.

164 replies1,604 reposts6,464 likesOpen on X