Story Texas Senate · Oct 9

How a conspiracy theory about James Talarico raced through the right-wing internet

NBC News's headline · Read the article

24accounts posting
17,165likes on their posts
72 hfrom first post to last

Posts on X we collected that mention it, Oct 9, 11:05 AM CT to Oct 16, 11:22 AM CT. Posts are not people, and replies include bots.

It started here

Mike (not a) Rothschild Oct 9, 11:05 AM CT

The people pushing the "Talarico had a breakdown" rumor are the same right wing influencers who always push these lies. Spencer Pratt, Laura Loomer, "Gunther Eagleman." They're the same people who don't say a word when Mitch McConnell or Tom Kean vanish for months.

Democratic state Rep. James Talarico has been off the trail for 12 days. His campaign says he is suffering from the flu and expected to be back in action this weekend.

2 replies18 reposts83 likesOpen on X

How it spread

noonSatnoonSunnoonMonpeak Sun 7 PM

Posts we collected about it, by the hour they were posted, Central time.

The loudest reactions swipe

Political Polls Oct 11, 7:34 PM CT

🔵 News - Ohio's Lindner Center of Hope says James Talarico was never a patient, shutting down speculation pushed by Elon Musk and right-wing accounts about his absence from the trail

186 replies435 reposts4,079 likesOpen on X

Michael Oct 11, 1:34 PM CT

Right-wing scam accounts desperately trying to invent this Talarico hoax story definitely makes me think the real internal polling is HORRIFIC for Paxton. This shit is so desperate.

123 replies257 reposts3,134 likesOpen on X

Chef Joe Gera 🏳️‍🌈🏳️‍⚧️🇮🇹 Oct 12, 9:54 PM CT

So, if y’all want to know WHY this absolutely made up bullshit about @jamestalarico was created this past Thursday, it was because of this story about @KenPaxtonTX in the @wsj which was running today. Ken Paxton was in Dubai with fugitives. This is why liars like @nicksortor @spencerpratt & other right wing influencers and yes even Elmo himself were enlisted to help.

As Trump weighed endorsing Ken Paxton, he was told that damaging revelations were likely to surface, people familiar with the conversations say. Now, the decision to endorse the Texas attorney general looks like Trump’s biggest gamble of the midterms.

32 replies589 reposts2,607 likesOpen on X

Krystal Ball Oct 11, 7:23 PM CT

What a shocker that right wing grifters made up some easily disproven nonsense and a ton of idiots bought it hook line and sinker.

Representative James Talarico has never received treatment from Lindner Center of Hope.

96 replies185 reposts2,207 likesOpen on X

Brian Krassenstein Oct 11, 8:01 PM CT

I warned you all that they were going to try and pull this James Talarico crap earlier this morning before it all started. That’s because one of the people who were initially involved in this idiotic story realized how ridiculous it all was and decided to text me about it last night.

WARNING: A bunch of right wing influencers are trying to concoct a story about James Tallarico. Expect a bunch of lies over the course of the next 24 hours.

183 replies247 reposts1,850 likesOpen on X

Matthew Chapman Oct 13, 4:16 AM CT

Somehow the shoes aren't even done dropping for Ken Paxton. This story about him partying in Dubai with two federally wanted fugitives is completely insane. No wonder right-wing influencers were working around the clock desperately trying to manufacture a fake story about James Talarico being at a mental hospital in Ohio.

47 replies249 reposts1,389 likesOpen on X

Where the race stands

Senate

James Talarico50%
Ken Paxton44%

YouGov's numbers, not VoteCow's · September 28 - October 5, 2026 · 3,625 likely voters · ±3% · Release

Next storyTalarico rallies in San Marcos as high-stakes Texas Senate race enters final stretch32 accounts · 16,207 likes

More stories